Best time to post in r/youtubers

r/youtubers rules: what actually gets removed

Each rule below is paired with the way it is most likely enforced. Where the rules state a number, we quote it. Where they do not, we say so instead of guessing.

1. 1.We Do Not Issue Temporary Bans

   Enforcement varies

   This subreddit attracts a lot of spam, low-quality content, and lost users; it is extremely labor-intensive to run and therefore we DO NOT give second chances. Either you abide by the rules or you get banned permanently. Ignorance of the rules is no excuse - they are right here in white and black (or black and white if you're a Light Mode user)

2. 2.This subreddit is for established YouTube creators only

   Enforcement varies

   r/YouTubers is a community for people who are already creating content on YouTube and want to improve their channels, strategy, and craft. It is not for people who are “thinking about starting,” have not uploaded yet, or are just here as viewers/fans. Basic “How do I start a channel / get views / get monetized?” questions and general YouTube troubleshooting are not allowed. Subreddits for New YouTubers exist - use them instead.

3. 3.No self-promotion or engagement begging

   Enforcement varies

   You may not link your own videos or channel in posts or comments, or ask others to share theirs, except where explicitly allowed (e.g., the Monthly Show-Off Thread and properly formatted Review/Critique posts). No “check out my channel,” “Is my latest video good?”, “sub for sub,” “watch time exchanges,” or “DM me for collab/Discord” posts or comments. Promotion of non-YouTube content (apps, tools, services, coaching, courses, etc.) or referral/affiliate codes is never allowed.

4. 4.Review & Critique Posts Have Strict Format and Requirements

   Enforced automatically

   [Review Video] and [Channel Critique] posts are heavily regulated to keep them useful and fair. Misuse of these posts will result in loss of privileges or a full ban. These posts will be restricted by User Flair. Refer to the Wiki for the specific format and rules for these posts.

5. 5.No Spam, Surveys, Services, or Hoodwinkery

   Enforcement varies

   Posts or comments that exist primarily to sell, promote, or drive traffic to a product, service, app, platform, course, survey, or website are considered spam and you will be banned for it. This includes “feedback forms,” “market research,” “beta tests,” and disguised self-promo (“I found this great tool…”). Any kind of trickery, auto-subscribing links, or failure to disclose your relationship to what you’re linking will result in an immediate and permanent ban.

6. 6.Be Civil and Stay on Topic

   Enforcement varies

   Keep discussion professional and respectful. Personal attacks, harassment, bigotry, or dog-piling are not permitted. This subreddit is for creator-side discussion, not viewer gossip or drama: no threads about other YouTubers’ personal lives, cancel culture, or “what about this YouTuber?” posts. General YouTube “news” or rants are only allowed when they’re clearly framed around how it affects creators and their work.

7. 7.Posting Requires Verified Flair and Ongoing Good Standing

   Enforcement varies

   To post or comment here, you must have a user flair obtained by reading the rules and agreeing to them in the pinned instructions post. Additional flair levels (based on your subreddit karma and participation) unlock more types of posts, such as Tips & Tricks, Review/Critique threads, and Show-Off participation. Poor-quality comments or posts will result in loss of privileges. Misuse of Post Flairs or attempting to subvert the system will result in an immediate permanent ban.

8. 8.No discussion of AI content creation, enhancements, tools, or workflows

   Enforcement varies

   If you are going to be lazy and rely on AI to do your work (poorly) for you, you can rely on AI to (also poorly) answer your questions. Discussions here are to be focused on human-created content and human-centric workflows. Any mention of having an AI-generated channel, content, or workflow, or any suggestion to "Just Let AI Do It, Bro" will result in an immediate ban.

r/youtubers does not publish karma or account-age minimums in its rules. Subreddits often enforce unpublished filters on top of what they write down, which is why posts from new accounts can vanish without a message here.